WEB DESK: Climate negotiators have raised concerns over a lengthy and controversial draft agreement at COP31, warning that significant disagreements could complicate efforts to reach a consensus before the UN climate conference concludes in Turkey later this week.
The 18-page draft “cover decision”, released by co-host Australia, addresses a wide range of contentious issues, including phasing out fossil fuels, protecting climate science and providing financial support to developing countries.
European Union climate envoy Wopke Hoekstra criticised the document, saying the negotiations should remain focused on implementing existing climate commitments rather than reopening previously settled disputes.
Speaking in Antalya, Hoekstra warned that the draft could make the negotiation process “untenable”. He later told reporters that although the text contained some proposals supported by the EU, it resembled a lengthy list of demands and required substantial revisions.
Some European officials also described the document as an attempt to accommodate every country’s demands without establishing a clear direction.
Australian Climate Minister Chris Bowen, who is leading the negotiations, acknowledged that the draft contained proposals that did not have the support of all participating countries. He said at least one additional version would be presented before the conference ends.
Consensus remains a major hurdle
The negotiations are scheduled to conclude on Friday, although previous UN climate conferences have frequently extended beyond their deadlines because agreements require unanimous approval.
A Latin American official, speaking anonymously, criticised the draft for being excessively lengthy and warned that time was running out.
Another European negotiator called Australia’s approach a “kitchen sink” strategy, arguing that the document attempted to incorporate too many competing proposals.
Among its controversial provisions is a proposed requirement for wealthy nations to achieve net-zero emissions by 2030, a target widely viewed by officials as unrealistic.
A European official accused emerging economies of using the negotiations to place additional obligations on developed countries, particularly on issues that several European nations consider unacceptable.
Dispute over fossil fuel phaseout
The proposed language on phasing out fossil fuels has emerged as another major source of disagreement, with oil-producing countries historically opposing such commitments.
Antigua and Barbuda Environment Minister Michael Joseph said his country wanted a clear commitment to ending the use of fossil fuels but acknowledged that securing agreement on the issue at COP31 could prove extremely difficult.
A separate dispute has emerged over the publication schedule of the United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) assessment reports.
Several European, African and Pacific countries want the next assessment reports released before the global stocktake scheduled for COP33 in 2028, which will evaluate progress towards reducing global emissions.
However, Saudi Arabia and India are among the countries reportedly favouring a later publication date of 2029 for the IPCC’s seventh assessment report.
Defending its position, Saudi Arabia’s COP31 delegation said the publication schedule should allow adequate time for scientific review, transparency and meaningful participation, particularly by developing nations.
Ilana Seid, chair of the Alliance of Small Island States, stressed that the IPCC report must be available before the global stocktake, describing any delay as unjustifiable.

