Abb Takk News
HeadlinesMOST POPULARNews TickerPakistanTop NewsTRENDING

Ministers spar with Bilawal over calls for new provinces

ISLAMABAD: Federal and provincial leaders have criticised PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari over his opposition to dividing Sindh, intensifying a debate about public consent, provincial identity and the constitutional process for creating new provinces.

Bilawal has said any new province must be established through constitutional and legal procedures and with the public’s support. He warned that imposing a division of Sindh could fuel social tensions and violence. He also opposed a referendum, arguing that such votes had been used for undemocratic purposes in the past.

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif said political change required public backing and that consulting citizens should not be dismissed as a “backdoor” approach. Parliament could debate the issue while considering public views, he said. Asif also criticised the PPP’s record during its 18 years in power in Sindh, pointing to conditions in Karachi.

Federal Health Minister and MQM-P leader Mustafa Kamal described smaller provinces as necessary for Pakistan’s effective governance. Speaking in Karachi, he called a referendum the best way to establish public opinion and said the prime minister had the authority to hold one. Kamal also blamed the PPP for failing to direct federal funds and devolved powers to the grassroots, and criticised its record on local government.

Kamal referred to past violence against the Muhajir community and warned Bilawal against statements that could inflame tensions. He also alleged that Karachi residents had been undercounted and were not receiving a fair share of development funding.

Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Ahmad Khan questioned why the PPP had supported a resolution concerning the division of Punjab but opposed discussing a split in Sindh. He said debate should continue and that the Constitution provided for a referendum, while negotiations could help resolve the issue.

PPP leader Saeed Ghani defended Bilawal, saying his comments had been misrepresented. Ghani accused the MQM of stoking hostility and argued that the Constitution should not be applied selectively. He said Sindh’s political stability should be respected, even by those who disagreed with the PPP.

Minister of State for Interior Talal Chaudhry also challenged the PPP’s governance record, saying the party shared responsibility for government performance. He argued that new administrative units should be considered where poor governance and corruption persisted.

Sindh government spokesperson Sumeta Afzal responded by urging federal ministers to uphold the Constitution. She said the PPP would resist efforts to frame the party’s political agenda as a constitutional debate against Sindh, and cited the party’s record of support for democracy, provincial autonomy and the Constitution.

Bilawal has maintained that neither the prime minister nor the cabinet has discussed creating new provinces with him or President Asif Ali Zardari. He has also said the Sindh Assembly has repeatedly opposed dividing the province, and urged Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif to work with the Sindh government on public concerns.