ISLAMABAD: The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) has expressed serious concerns over the independence of Pakistan’s judiciary, saying constitutional and legislative changes introduced through the 26th and 27th amendments have weakened the courts’ ability to hold the government accountable.
In a report released on Wednesday, the international legal organisation concluded that the combined impact of the amendments had undermined judicial independence and restricted the judiciary’s capacity to provide effective remedies for human rights violations.
“The 26th and 27th amendments have done exactly what we feared: they have placed Pakistan’s highest courts under the control of the executive,” ICJ Secretary-General Santiago Canton said.
He warned that weakening judicial autonomy would leave citizens without an effective institution to hold the government accountable or seek justice for human rights abuses.
The report examines the constitutional and institutional framework governing Pakistan’s high courts, Supreme Court and newly established Federal Constitutional Court (FCC), assessing it against the country’s international legal obligations.
It was published a year after the 27th Amendment was enacted in November 2025 and two years after the 26th Amendment was passed in October 2024.
The 26th Amendment introduced sweeping changes to the judicial system, including the removal of the Supreme Court’s suo motu powers, fixing the chief justice of Pakistan’s tenure at three years and authorising the prime minister to select the next chief justice from among the three most senior Supreme Court judges.
The 27th Amendment brought further structural changes, most notably the establishment of the Federal Constitutional Court, alongside changes to the military’s chain of command and the granting of immunities to senior public officeholders.
According to the ICJ, the cumulative impact of these changes and their implementation has deprived Pakistan’s highest courts of institutional safeguards necessary for judicial independence under Article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the UN Basic Principles on the Independence of the Judiciary.
The organisation also warned that the changes had weakened the right to an effective legal remedy for victims of human rights violations, protected under Article 2(3) of the ICCPR and Pakistan’s domestic laws.
The ICJ acknowledged that Pakistan’s judicial system had long required reforms, particularly regarding transparency and inclusiveness in judicial appointments. It also noted its previous concerns about judicial overreach and interference in the responsibilities of parliament and other state institutions.
However, Canton argued that these shortcomings had not been addressed through the constitutional changes.
“Pakistan’s judiciary needed reform. Judges were appointed without transparency, and at times the courts overstepped into the domain of other institutions. None of these problems has been fixed,” he said, adding that public dissatisfaction with the judiciary had instead been used to justify greater executive control.
The ICJ has called for substantial constitutional and legislative reforms to address the concerns identified in its report. It recommended revising or repealing provisions of the 26th and 27th amendments that conflict with international standards governing judicial independence.

