ISLAMABAD: Islamabad High Court (IHC) has reserved its verdict on Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) leader Faisal Vawda’s plea challenging Election Commission of Pakistan’s (ECP) verdict of disqualifying him for life.
The IHC Chief Justice Athar Minallah heard the case. During the hearing, Faisal Vawda’s counsel Waseem Sajjad argued that ECP is not court of law, therefore, the high court should annul its judgment. My client didn’t lie in affidavit deliberately.
The lawyer based his case on the argument that the ECP is not a court of law therefore it lacks authority to disqualify Vawda for life.
“The ECP cannot invoke Article 62(1)(f) of the Constitution and disqualify Vawda for life,” he said.
At this, Justice Minallah remarked: “The affidavit had been submitted in light of a Supreme Court’s order [requiring a certificate for the renunciation of foreign nationalities]. You are basing your arguments on technical grounds.”
The chief justice asked Advocate Sajjad to point out the flaw in ECP’s decision.
Justice Minallah went on to say that the apex court had issued the order itself and made the submission of the affidavit a must. It also warned of serious consequences if the statement in the affidavit was found to be false, he added.
“Would the SC have investigated the authenticity of the affidavit [itself],” the CJ asked, adding that ECP was supposed to carry out the inquiry and send it to the apex court with the report that these are the consequences for submitting a false affidavit.
The court told the lawyer to prove the purity of Vawda’s intentions, based on the argument he didn’t hold dual nationality at the time of the affidavit’s submission.
“Did [Vawda] give up his US nationality before he submitted his nomination papers or not?” Justice Minallah inquired.
He also inquired about the date of renunciation of the US citizenship, and if the certificate proved it has been submitted.
At this, Advocate Sajjad maintained that the ECP can only probe the falsity or otherwise of the affidavit but the procedure after that has to be taken into account.
Responding to the query about the submission of the renunciation certificate, the lawyer said that the petitioner [of the plea seeking Vawda’s disqualification] also didn’t submit the certificate proving they surrendered their other nationalities.
“Lifetime disqualification is a death sentence for a politician,” he added.
At this, Justice Minallah remarked that many politicians have got this “death penalty”, and reserved the verdict on Vawda’s plea.
The ECP, while announcing the verdict for the PTI leader’s disqualification, had directed him to turn in all financial benefits and privileges he had been enjoying as a Senator within two months.
